Magazine
Management & Business

Hyatt and Hilton’s trademark dispute shows how independent hotels can protect their names

Hyatt and Hilton are fighting over a trademark. Ansgar Ohly and Dagmar Maurer explain how hotels can protect their names.

Hotel reception desk with a bell, a “Hotel” sign, a trademark law book and a ® symbol on the glass door, with round portraits of Ansgar Ohly and Dagmar Maurer
Professor Dr Ansgar Ohly and Dagmar Maurer explain how independent hotels can protect their names. Photos: Anna Pfister (Ansgar Ohly), DPMA (Dagmar Maurer)
Key points
  • In the US, Hyatt has opposed Hilton’s application for “Select by Hilton”. The proceedings are suspended for settlement talks.
  • A hotel name can be protected without registration, but that protection may remain regionally limited.
  • For business identifiers, the older right takes precedence over the newer one. The size of the business makes no difference.
  • The German trademark office does not check earlier third-party rights on application. Filing online costs €290 for up to three classes.

It is a single word that has brought two of the world’s largest hotel groups into a trademark dispute: “Select”. Hyatt uses it for its Hyatt Select hotel brand, while Hilton has chosen Select by Hilton for a new concept. Both companies have extensive trademark portfolios and decades of experience in hospitality. Yet their choice of names has created a conflict that has now reached the US trademark authorities.

On 26 October 2026, Hyatt filed an opposition to Hilton’s trademark application with the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB). Hyatt is relying on its registered Hyatt Select trademark and two additional trademark applications. The proceedings, numbered 91311383, were suspended on the same day to allow settlement negotiations. No decision has been issued, and no settlement has been publicly confirmed.¹

The two hotel groups are not even pursuing identical business models. Hyatt announced its new upper-midscale brand in February 2025.² Hilton filed its application for Select by Hilton in October 2025 before officially introducing the concept in March 2026.³⁴ Its approach is to connect existing hotel brands to the group’s distribution network and loyalty programme, with Yotel becoming the first participant. The different concepts make the dispute particularly interesting: how much protection can a hotel name actually provide?

An attractive name alone is not enough for trademark law

For an independent hotelier, a property’s name often means far more than a business identifier. It may have been chosen by a grandparent, reflect the history of the building or have accompanied the same family through generations. Guests associate it with holidays, encounters and personal memories. Trademark law, however, does not automatically protect that emotional significance. The starting point is whether a name distinguishes one provider from others.

Professor Dr Ansgar Ohly, who holds the Chair of Civil Law, Intellectual Property Law and Competition Law at Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, explains to eingecheckt® that under German and European law, trademarks must be distinctive rather than merely descriptive. Words such as “Luxury”, “Country House” or “Business”, used to describe a hotel, would generally not qualify for protection on their own. In Germany, he considers “Select” a borderline case: it might be regarded as descriptive, but it could also be just unusual enough in hotel naming to qualify for protection. The combination Hyatt Select, however, would certainly qualify for protection because of its distinctive company name element.

Ansgar Ohly in a dark jacket and white shirt smiles in front of the Siegestor in Munich
Professor Dr Ansgar Ohly in front of the Siegestor in Munich. Photo: Anna Pfister

This helps explain why imaginative or unusual names often provide a stronger legal starting point. A hotel that relies entirely on terms its competitors could reasonably use to describe their own properties may find it difficult to secure exclusive rights. Nor does adding a well-known company name necessarily remove the possibility of confusion with an earlier trademark. That depends on the specific signs and how consumers perceive them. The legal scholar’s observations concern German and European trademark law; they are not predictions about the outcome of the US proceedings.

Protection can arise without registration

What happens to a family-run hotel that has welcomed guests under the same name for 40 years but has never registered a trademark? Fortunately, the absence of a registered trademark does not necessarily mean that the name is unprotected. According to Ansgar Ohly, rights in a business identifier can arise through its actual use. The name must either be sufficiently distinctive or have become recognised among potential guests as referring to a particular business.

To illustrate the first possibility, the legal scholar invents the example of “Ohlys Sport- und Lifestylehotel”, where his relatively unusual surname would help distinguish the business. A common name such as “Hotel zur Post” presents a different situation. A hotel might be well known and protected under that name in its own region without acquiring exclusive rights throughout Germany. His hypothetical examples of Hotels zur Post in Kiefersfelden and Flensburg illustrate how protection can be geographically limited.

An entry in the commercial register or a long-standing website presence should therefore not be confused with a nationally registered trademark. For established businesses, the crucial question is whether enforceable rights have arisen through their use of a distinctive name and how far those rights extend. This distinction can become particularly important when a family hotel plans to expand its business or open additional properties.

In small versus large, the older name wins

The question becomes more pressing when a much larger competitor adopts a similar name. Does the independent hotelier have to accept that a company with greater financial resources will prevail? Legally, the size of a business does not automatically determine whose rights come first.

“As far as business identifiers are concerned, the older right takes precedence over the newer one. Size makes no difference,” explains Ansgar Ohly.

In practice, however, a registered trademark may make a hotel’s position considerably easier to enforce. Within its scope of protection, a German registration generally provides nationwide rights and can be particularly useful when dealing with online platforms. The legal scholar observes that such platforms are quicker to remove potentially infringing listings when presented with a registered trademark.

The German Patent and Trade Mark Office (DPMA) issued a warning in February 2026 that illustrates how serious the problem has become. Since mid-2025, the authority has observed an increase in suspicious applications involving names already used by businesses without registered trademark protection. Some applicants appear to be seeking registration in order to put existing users under pressure. The DPMA specifically highlights the mechanisms available on certain online marketplaces to block other users.⁵ For a hotel dependent on its digital visibility and booking channels, a naming dispute can therefore have consequences well beyond the legal correspondence.

The trademark office does not check earlier rights

Overlapping hotel names are hardly surprising to the German Patent and Trade Mark Office. Dagmar Maurer, Team Leader in the DPMA’s Trademarks Division, is familiar with the difficulties encountered by hospitality businesses. One recurring problem is the lack of sufficient distinctiveness.

Dagmar Maurer, wearing glasses and a light blue blazer, smiles against a pale background
Dagmar Maurer is Team Leader in the Trademarks Division of the German Patent and Trade Mark Office. Photo: DPMA

She gives geographically influenced names such as “Rhein-Glück” and “Ostseewinkel” as examples. Conventional hospitality names containing words such as castle, monastery or traditional inn are generally not eligible for protection either. The same applies to historic building names such as “Salzhaus”, or purely descriptive expressions such as “Sports Hotel” and “Family Hotel” combined with a place name. Such names may fit a property’s character perfectly, but that does not automatically make them registrable as word marks. Additional distinctive elements, such as a graphic, an illustration or a personal or company name, can make a difference.

There is another detail that may surprise hotel owners. When examining a trademark application, the DPMA assesses whether absolute grounds for refusal exist. It does not, as part of the ordinary application process, check whether someone else already holds earlier rights to an identical or similar name. A mark may therefore be registered initially and subsequently challenged by the holder of an earlier right.⁶

“With so many trademarks in existence, research is absolutely essential and time very well spent,” she says. Before introducing a new name, she recommends checking the DPMAregister and investigating whether similar names are already being used in the hotel and restaurant industry.

How to protect your hotel name
  1. Research before committing: Check the DPMAregister and search the web for existing identical or similar names and logos.
  2. Consider trademark registration: A distinctive name may qualify for registration as a word mark. Where a name is common, a distinctive additional element or individually designed logo may offer another possibility. Incorporating a personal or company name may also help.
  3. Keep evidence of use: Archive advertising materials and past versions of your website. These may help establish when and how extensively your hotel has used its name.
  4. Monitor new applications: Regularly search for similar hotel names and applications in the DPMAregister.

Trademark applications in hospitality are increasing

Trademark applications in Class 43
  1. 2024: 2,054 applications
  2. 2025: 2,231 applications
  3. 2026: more than 2,500 applications expected

These figures come from the DPMA and cover the whole of Class 43, which includes accommodation and food services. They do not represent hotel businesses alone. Across all sectors, the DPMA receives more than 90,000 trademark applications annually.

Filing costs €290 for ten years

Compared with many other investments involved in running a hotel, the official application fees are relatively modest. The DPMA currently charges €290 for an electronic German trademark application covering up to three classes of goods or services. A paper application costs €300, while each additional class adds €100. Initial protection lasts ten years and can be renewed. The current renewal fee for a further ten years is €750 for up to three classes.⁷

Paying the fee does not guarantee registration. If a name fails to meet the legal requirements, the application may be refused. According to the DPMA, around 80 per cent of marks are eligible for registration, and the certificate is then usually issued within a few months. Research, potential disputes and professional legal advice must also be considered.

For independent hoteliers, the most practical lesson from the dispute between Hyatt and Hilton is to understand the rights attached to a name before a conflict arises.

Dagmar Maurer offers an encouraging perspective from the trademark office: “Anyone can create a good trademark. And a trademark can, in principle, live forever.”

This article provides general information and is not a substitute for legal advice on individual circumstances.

Sources

This article is based on official trademark records, hotel company announcements, information from the German Patent and Trade Mark Office and original editorial interviews.

  1. United States Patent and Trademark Office (2026)
    TTAB Opposition No. 91311383: Hyatt Corporation v Hilton International Holding LLC
    Case file, accessed on 5 November 2026. Opposition, trademark rights and suspension of 26 October 2026.
  2. Hyatt Hotels Corporation (2025)
    Hyatt Select Announced as Hyatt’s First Conversion-Friendly Transient Brand in the Upper-Midscale Segment in the Americas
    Announcement of 25 February 2025. Launch of the Hyatt Select brand.
  3. One Mile at a Time (2026)
    Messy Hotel Trademark Battle: Hyatt Select Vs. Select By Hilton
    Article of 29 October 2026. Select by Hilton application filed in October 2025.
  4. Hilton (2026)
    Hilton Announces Exclusive Agreement with YOTEL
    Announcement of 19 March 2026. Launch of Select by Hilton and partnership with Yotel.
  5. German Patent and Trade Mark Office (2026)
    Hinweis auf den Anstieg bösgläubiger Markenanmeldungen
    Notice of 11 February 2026. Suspicious applications and blocking mechanisms on online marketplaces. Original publication in German.
  6. German Patent and Trade Mark Office (2026)
    Prüfung, Eintragung und Verlängerung von Marken
    Information page, as at 12 March 2026. Absolute grounds for refusal and earlier rights. Original publication in German.
  7. German Patent and Trade Mark Office (2026)
    Markengebühren im Überblick
    Fee schedule, as at 29 September 2026. Official application and renewal fees. Original publication in German.
Original editorial source: Written interviews with Professor Dr Ansgar Ohly, Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, and Dagmar Maurer, German Patent and Trade Mark Office, November 2026. Answers and quotations translated from German by the eingecheckt editorial team.